It is not always greener on the other side: Greenery perception across demographics and personalities in multiple cities
Abstract
Quantifying and assessing urban greenery is consequential for planning and development, reflecting the everlasting importance of green spaces for multiple climate and well-being dimensions of cities. Evaluation can be broadly grouped into objective (e.g., measuring the amount of greenery) and subjective (e.g., polling the perception of people) approaches, which may differ – what people see and feel about how green a place is might not match the measurements of the actual amount of vegetation. In this work, we advance the state of the art by measuring such differences and explaining them through human, geographic, and spatial dimensions. The experiments rely on contextual information extracted from street view imagery and a comprehensive urban visual perception survey collected from 1000 people across five countries with their extensive demographic and personality information. We analyze the discrepancies between objective measures (e.g., Green View Index (GVI)) and subjective scores (e.g., pairwise ratings), examining whether they can be explained by a variety of human and visual factors such as age group and spatial variation of greenery in the scene. The findings reveal that such discrepancies are comparable around the world and that demographics and personality do not play a significant role in perception. Further, while perceived and measured greenery correlate consistently across geographies (both where people and where imagery are from), where people live plays a significant role in explaining perceptual differences, with these two, as the top among seven, features that influences perceived greenery the most. This location influence suggests that cultural, environmental, and experiential factors substantially shape how individuals observe greenery in cities. We also found that the spatial arrangement of greenery in the sight, rather than its proximity to the person, influences perception. Our study provides a new understanding of the deep relationships between objective and subjective street-level greenery assessments, contributing to a more human-centric design of green urban environments.
Matias Quintana
Research Fellow
Jussi Torkko
Visiting Scholar
Youlong Gu
Research Engineer
Xiucheng Liang
PhD Researcher
Yujun Hou
Research Associate
Koichi Ito
PhD Researcher
Yihan Zhu
PhD Researcher
Mahmoud Abdelrahman
Research Fellow
